Banning things, generally

I wrote before that I wasn't that persuaded by the case against banning incandescent lights, as Labour had wanted to do. Udayan criticsed me for a lack of analysis. This is my 'how do you like me now' post.
Here is a very simplified, non-paternalistic argument for banning certain things in the face of climate change.

People tend to operate with an implicit social discount rate. Although they may be aware that their actions are harming future generations, they tend to value their own economic security and well-being over that of future generations. Left to their own devices, most people won't radically adjust their behaviour until they are faced with tangible negative consequences. The nature of global warming may be such that by this point, it is irreversible (I have little idea as to whether this is true, but it doesn't seem outrageous). So we are essentially saving future generations from the excesses of modern ones, or stopping temporal externalities.
Whether or not we should place moral importance on future generations is an interesting question, and you may think that we should not. Here is a good intro to the topic.

But we can avoid this issue. There are many people in the world that have little in the way of a carbon footprint. They are for the most part destitutely poor. Yet the externalities from carbon emitting processes are global. So we are saving the poor from the emissions of the rich, so to speak.

If you're still reading, it should be clear that the case is not at all paternalistic, as many would have it. But you may still ask, why not just tax the externalities? Why ban the process completely?

Here we have to be case by case. We obviously can't ban things that have little in the way of feasible substitutes available in the short term, like cars. But as the philosopher Robert Nozick argues, it is frequently not morally acceptable to injure someone and then subsequently grant compensation. You can't rape someone and get out of prison simply by paying them off. Some acts actually should be prohibited. And if you think you can contribute to flooding and suffering in the third world and get off by chucking them some aid, you are wrong.


Disclaimer: I should note that I am not completely persuaded by the case I have just put forward. But I wanted to show that this is not a case of cut and dried paternalism, nor necessarily a case of Right vs. Left, although it may seem so on the surface.

I have a feeling many of my friends will disagree with me, I encourage you guys to say why.

Blogroll

Notebook Sony
Environmental Learning
Laws and Theories
Offerte Netbook
Villas and Apartments
Best Marketing Strategies
The Best Online Dating Tips
Christmas Holidays
Learning Web Design
Hospital Epidemiology and Infection Control
Emergency Cash Loans
Brain Radiation Treatment
Construction Jobs and Careers
Business Funding Solutions
Prescription Drug Information
Drug Rehabilitation care
Better Economy Calculator
Printing Supplies and Accessories
Sports Training Academy
Western Inc
Chinese Rehabilitation Center
Chinese Treatment Centre
Golden Pacific Apartment
Human Rights Watch
Business Travel Industry
Healthy During Pregnancy
Top Media Agencies
Auto Dealer and Business
Liberty Capital Financial
Auto Parts and Auto Accessories
Educational Ideals
Automotive Mechanic
Holiday Vacations and Travel
Weddings and Honeymoons
Home Repair Projects
Manufacture Real Estate Investing
Entertainment Express
Employees Insurance Agency
Diet and Fitness Tips
Architectural Design on Real Estate
Jewelry and Accessories
Journal of Health Medical Informatics
Nights and Holiday
Recreational Sports and Facilities
generation
Top Media Agencies Automotive Mechanic Recreational Sports and Facilities Teahouse Restaurant Healthy Families and Relationships Better Homes and Gardens Moving and Storage Services Greener Business Lawyer and Attorney Careers Best Business Opportunities Cosmetic Surgery and Plastic Surgery Website Design and Online Marketing Planning Strategy for Writing High and Low Finance Home and Property Insurance Health and safety Construction
Newtown Solutions
Business and Keeping Records
Hypnotherapy and Spiritual
Computing and Software Systems
Web and Graphic Design
Web Games Graphic
Web Graphics Tutorial
Computer Graphics Technology
anabolic steroids
dietpittsburgh
loseweightpittsburgh
notquietart
mswlea
fatlosspittsburgh
bmipittsburgh
allstonbrighton
nutrisystpittsburgh
obesitypittsburgh
calmart
personaltrainerspittsburgh
jenycraipittsburgh
curvepittsburgh
richardsandgeorgia
robsonandrichards
News Fashion
Auto Insurance
Business Online
Prevent Drugs
Computer Society
Wedding Ring Jewelry
Austria hotel deals
Computer games USA
Studio Design Decorative
Journalism Careers
Gaming Accessories Computing
Business Strategy Consultant
Cefori Technologies Information
Physics and Astronomy
Legal Defense and Educational
Business, Finance and Investment
Starting A Business
Economics Working Papers
Real Estate Investing Resources
Marketing Lessons and Training
SEO Marketing Solution
Sales Marketing Tools
Chlamydia Test – STD Home Tests – STI Tests
Safety Health Training
Essay Writing and Research Paper
Childrens Education
World of Mushrooms
Cancer Care Resources
Installment Loans Online Source
Real Estate and Home for Sale
Find Cheap Vacation Packages
Modern Healthy Lifestyle, Nutrition and Fitness
Pikes Peak International Raceway
Down Syndrome Research and Treatment
Knight Online World
Creative Handbook
Home Improvement and Remodeling
E-Commerce Learning
Custom Essay Writing and Research Paper
Online Education
Insurance and Finance
Cancer Treatment Resources
Renewable Energy Resources
Health's HIV/Aids Medical Care
Daily Discount Coupons
Hotels and Resorts
Limo and Car Services
Dental Health and Fluoride Treatment
Possum Point Players
Motorhome Advice and Tips
Disease Research Center
e-Consultation Technologies
Wedding Supply Catalogs
Computer Imaging for Medical Applications
Wedding and Engagement Rings
Webcam Modeling
Healthcare Technology
House Architecture Design Garden Advice
Real Estate and Property
Luxury Weddings Planners
Laws, Legal and Attorneys Information
Alcohol Rehab And Drug Addiction Treatment
Vintage Clothing and Jewelry
College of Education
Federation British Lawyer Society
Windows Networking Solutions User Group
Free Open Source Software
Internet Storage Name Service
On-line Real Estate System Information
Worker Safety and Health
Occupational Safety and Health
Workplace Safety and Health
Health and Safety at Work
Health and Safety Training
Occupational Safety and Health Training
OSHA Safety and Health
OSHA Training and Safety Program
OSHA and Workplace Safety Training
Occupational Safety and Health Program
OSHA Training and Reference
Healthy Mind and Body
Personal Loans Bad Credit
Technology and Communication
Cash Advance Payday Loans Online
Climate Dialogue
State Science and Engineering
Prague City Golf
Green Home Plans
Arts, Entertainment , Music, Film, Television, Opera Ballet
Kitchen and Bathroom Design
Online Poker Rankings and Internet Poker Player Stats
Business Enterprise Management
Lawyer, Attorney, Law Firms, Attorneys, Legal Information
Workplace Safety and Health
Health Club, Gym and Fitness Center
Pbs Technology Solutions
Global Audit Services
Sterling Health and Wellness
Luxury Real Estate
Auto Body Repair | Automotive Concepts
Green Public Housing
Even Design
Web Hosting and Development
Hotel Deals and Reviews
Expanding Your Life
Shopping and Style
Find the Best College for You
Motorhomes
Home Equity Loans
Residency Training Program
Tips on Writing Newspaper Editorial Format
Social Media Marketing Tips
Occupational Health and Safety
European Law and Economics
Technology and Science Information
Celebrate Travel and Tourism
Island travel destination guides
Small Business and Finance
Art and Entertainment Information
Antique Flooring and Carpet Tiles
Gay and Lesbian Couples
Deep Insurance Solutions
FindLaw Lawyers Directory
Beverly Hills Spa and Hotel
Travel Tips and Guide
Most Popular TV Shows
Discount Online Shopping
Heart Disease Symptoms
Women's Health
Graduate Institute for Development Studies
Cirius Technologies USA
SEO Tips and Strategies
Medicinal Products: Prescription
The Importance of Education Programs
Skin Care, Acne Treatment, Anti Aging, Beauty and Skin Lotion
Natural Health and Beauty
Computer and Internet
Get The Cheapest Flight Deals
Plastic Surgery, Cosmetic Surgery and Hair Transplant
Custom Software and Web Design
Love Bites
Island Real Estate
Perfect Home Living
Home Improvement and Remodeling
Loans Online
Essay Writing Help - Essay Writing Service
Feelings and Emotions
Stock Market Financial Markets
Free Recipe Home
Online Casino Club
Residential Real Estate Investment
21
22
23
24
25
26
wash vanilla taksi tampere simply cotton web design qualifax ccccsvs czagh Hypnotherapy and Spiritual Computing and Software Systems Cheap Hotel Rooms Real Estate Sales and Liquidation Central Clothing Web Service Clients Museum Studies Insurance Services Internet service Traveling Hotel Reviews Information Legal News Health Casino Gambling Health and Drugs News Fashion Auto Insurance Business Online Prevent Drugs Michigan Apartments Digital Entertainment Real Estate and Property Quality Natural Herbal Medicine estate quality Products Travel synergistic literature safety industry Game Spare Parts Automotive Fashion Store Design Contractors in Real Estate Career Lawyer Information Stores for Home Improvement Clothing Stores Online Golf Equipment Shops Loan Amounts and Rates Media Section Publications Business Marketing Campaigns Computer communications Sports and Fitness Trainers Gaming Club Online Home Decorating and Staging Medical Supplies and Equipment Homes and Gardens Furniture Business Print and Design Business Print Services Hotel Reservation Information Travelling Family Creative Kids Education Centre Science Educator Guide Commerce and Industry Social Network Innovation Technologies and Environmental Media Writing Tips Innovation in Travel Housing and Real Estate Holiday Activity Guide Clean Water for Health Quotes About Education Pioneer Law Ultimate Foods for Ultimate Health Identity and Access Management Software Efficient Healthcare Medical Leadership and Management Pride of Texas Real Estate Information Marketing Business Favorite Health Blogs Complementary and Alternative Medicine Healthy Nourishment Natural Healthy Food Cowtown Tour Dates and Tickets Professional Coin Grading Service Hypnosis and Hypnotherapy Holiday Activity Guide Sport Education Program Clean Water for Health Quotes About Education Online Fashion Shopping Guide World Business Information Life Insurance Systems Social Network Radio Education Books for Kids Institute of Medicine Hot Medical Careers Drugs and Supplements Marketing Strategies For Business Search Engine Marketing Online Gambling Games News Entertainment and Arts Entertainment News For Kids Information Architecture Institute of Technology Learning Games For Kids Internet Marketing Services Home Improvement Loans Physics Lab Equipment Education and Science Society Electronic and Computer Engineering Prom Dresses Modest Your Baby Book movingimage abc depannage koncepcja well shops kvadro bowwow heisinger 2012 funtime travel shop scati elmhurst dance education mentors zoomy stech1 life simpli fied self publish pay day loans
life insurance quotes
Credit Loans (finance)
Foreign Auto Parts
Health and Fitness
Drug abuse effects
Destination hotels and resorts
Professional Financial Marketing
Personal Finance
Computers and Technology
Auto Insurance
Real Estate Property
Computer Graphics Technology
Home Improvement
Arts music schools
Online Education Classes
Hotel and Travel
Security development program
Business auto loans
Medical And Public Health Organizations
Land and Homes
azplanningforwildlife.com m2tvchannel.com bapedaldaprovjambi.com kreis-dl.net news-1212.com landratsamt-doebeln.net landkreis-doebeln.net canadiangoldreserves.net chicagohearse.com tattooremovalessex.com braziltrade-uae.com 333asia.com calliemacdesigns.com gemdoc.net simplefoodjuiceplus.com postabortionstresssyndrome.com descendingpath.com casadopinhole.net myspeechandlanguage.net sezambook.com rerecognition.info bebetsy.info carsoncitybraces.info summitcardiology.info sanfojiangsi.info trailheadgeararchery.info immigrationconnect.info nhhomeless.info tundradialogues.info ibexretail.com kreis-dl.com agiles-eam.com bestbcgolfcourse.com niittyneito.com yenikapimevlevihanesi.com hnr100.com eplogin.com richard-wagner-festival.com landratsamt-doebeln.com lra-doebeln.com terrecatalane.com thesmarterhybrids.com